News and views from the award-winning author of the novels The Skinny Years, America Libre, House Divided and Pancho Land

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

Disturbing poll results

A CBS/New York Times poll released May 2 regarding Arizona SB1070 found 51% of Americans think the new law “is about right.” Only 36% thought the law “goes too far.”

A May 4 New York Times article reported: “Although the respondents broadly agreed that the Arizona law would result in racial profiling, overburden local and state law enforcement agencies and decrease the willingness of illegal immigrants to report crimes for fear of deportation, large majorities said it would reduce the number of illegal immigrants in the state, deter illegal border crossings and, to a lesser extent, reduce crime.”

This is a very disturbing revelation. Because here’s what this poll says to me about the attitude among 51% of Americans:

  • Racial profiling of innocent Hispanics: OK with me.
  • Overburdening of local law officers with enforcement of victimless crimes: OK with me.
  • Reducing the ability of police to investigate serious crimes: OK with me.
  • Having undocumented workers earn an honest living: I’ve got a problem with that.

Don’t get me wrong. The issue of illegal immigration is a serious problem. But the solution offered by this simplistic law seems more about spite than reason. Surely there were Japanese spies in California at the outset of WWII. But was that justification for interning every single Japanese? This law is little different. It says we are willing to trample the rights of a minority group to placate the fears of the majority. That tyranny by the majority is why the Founders insisted on a Bill of Rights in the U.S. Constitution. (By the way, where is the outcry from the Tea Baggers about “defending the Constitution” on this one?)

There are over 45 million Hispanics in the United States today. The overwhelming majority of them are here legally. I think it’s also a safe bet most of those Hispanics find this law punitive and petty. I certainly do.

If these poll numbers represent an accurate portrayal of mainstream attitudes, this nation is in for a long and divisive time ahead.

Raul Ramos y Sanchez

1 comment:

Jonathan said...

You and Jared Taylor should have a debate.

"What we have here is the old, old story of non-whites calling any rule they can’t follow “racist.” Are more blacks than whites barred from voting when felons are disfranchised? The rules are racist. Do blacks and Hispanics fail the promotion exam for police sergeant? The exam is racist. Do blacks and Hispanics violate the University of Virginia honor code more often than whites? The honor code is racist. Do they get expelled from school more often? Teachers are racist. Do they have low IQs? The tests are racist. Are Hispanics most likely to be deported if the law is enforced? The law is racist."